`

'Penalising solidarity with Palestinians': Lewisham Islamic Centre rejects Charity Commission warning

The mosque has rejected the official warning from the charities regulator for hosting 'inflammatory and divisive' sermons and says it is seeking legal advice.

'Penalising solidarity with Palestinians': Lewisham Islamic Centre rejects Charity Commission warning
Lewisham Islamic Centre. Image: Mark Morris

Lewisham Islamic Centre (LIC) has rejected the official warning issued by the Charity Commission for hosting “inflammatory and divisive” sermons which the commission has made public.

In a press statement, LIC said the Charity Commission was undertaking “a troubling attempt to scrutinise, restrict and penalise legitimate religious worship, the expression of solidarity with the Palestinian people, and the activities of a Muslim charitable institution.”

The Commission issued the warning largely in relation to two sermons which were given in October 2023 and August 2024 stating: “After assessing the evidence related to these and other events held at the charity, the regulator made a finding of misconduct and/or mismanagement.

“This was connected, but not limited to, two sermons hosted by the charity that included content that was inflammatory, divisive and not in the charity’s best interests.”

The commission’s official warning sets out that the mosque must now ensure that “all activity on its premises furthers its objects, benefits the public and is in its best interests”. In addition the mosque is required to review and implement a “robust and suitable events and speakers policy”.

The LIC statement argues that making the warning public was disproportionate and that adequate reasons for this have not been given: “While issuing a public warning is not mandatory and, in our view, was overzealous in the circumstances of this particular case, given that the matters of concern could quite easily have been dealt with by way of regulatory advice, the Commission has nevertheless failed to provide adequate reasons for considering it necessary to publish an official warning”.

Charity Commission guidance on the use and publication of official warnings to charities states that publication will "promote transparency".

“Publication can alert charities and members of the public or potential donors to actions within a charity which been a cause for regulatory concern .. It will assist in promoting public trust and confidence in the sector.”

'Penalised for expressing solidarity with Palestinian people'

LIC said in its statement: “The Commission’s action takes issue with one of our Imam’s supplication for the people of Palestine, Gaza and Jerusalem, including prayers for their protection, healing and deliverance from oppression.

“These were acts of Islamic worship. They reflected the compassion, solidarity and religious responsibility felt by Muslims witnessing the immense suffering of the Palestinian people.”

It continues: “This is about more than one mosque or one charity.

"It is about whether Muslim institutions can discharge their religious and charitable responsibilities without being penalised for expressing solidarity with Palestine, conducting established forms of Islamic worship or addressing issues of concern to their congregations, including repudiation of Zionism or denunciation of the Israeli state for war crimes and genocide.

“Solidarity with the oppressed must not become grounds for charitable sanction.”

LIC said it is continuing to seek legal advice on the most appropriate course of action.

Charity Commission response

In response, a spokesperson for the Charity Commission said: “People come to us with concerns about charities large and small with a wide range of charitable purposes and links to communities of various faiths and none.

“Always guided by the facts and evidence, we will take action against a charity when the law requires it even if that means getting in the crosshairs of sensitive debates.”

They added: “Lawful freedom of speech is fundamental to any democracy and robust debate, differences of opinion, and oppositional world views have always been features of our vibrant charity sector – and always will be.

“But we are consistent and clear it is not in the best interest of a charity to give speeches, sermons or other communications that are inflammatory and/or divisive.”

The Commission has said it may take further regulatory action if LIC fails to “remedy the misconduct”.

 The sermons at the centre of the complaint 

During a sermon on 20 October 2023, two weeks after the 7 October attack by Hamas, Imam Shakeel Begg said “the Muslims of Palestine and the people of Palestine have been suffering at the hands of the oppressors and the Zionists”.

Another sermon that took place on 9 October 2024 heard from Imam Ashraf Dabous, a trustee and the charity’s Deputy Imam.

The sermon followed weeks of violent, racists riots across England, which began with Islamophobic misinformation on social media after the attacks in Southport in July 2024.

Referring to the rioters, Dabous said “their manipulators are Zionists, and they are supporters of the state of Israel”.

He added: “With the ground that has been lost over the last few months, something had to take place that would try to win some ground back on the ground for the Zionist agenda.

“And what a better way than to paint the Muslims as being savages and killers and barbaric and so on and so forth and which in reality is a projection of the Zionist state itself.”


Lewisham Islamic Centre were contacted for further comment. Their press statement can be seen here. 

The Charity Commission’s official warning can be seen on their website here along with their press release.

The two sermons are available on YouTube.

Sign-up for our free weekly newsletter - Salamander News in your inbox